Skip to content
  • by
  • News
  • 3 min read

The Role of AI in Game Development: The Prospects and Concerns

In a recent interview, Tom Hall, the co-founder of id Software and one of the creators of the original DOOM, expressed his excitement about the ethical applications of artificial intelligence (AI) in game development. He believes that AI can enhance gameplay by generating content based on the player's preferences and adapting to their actions seamlessly. However, Hall also raises concerns about the potential homogenization of games if AI is overused.

Hall emphasizes the importance of maintaining a sense of craft and not relying solely on procedural generation. He uses the example of many AAA games that follow a repetitive pattern of attacking and dodging, suggesting that an overreliance on AI could lead to a lack of creativity and diversity in game design. He envisions AI as a tool that enables developers to create cooler and more amazing experiences, but still acknowledges the need for human craftsmanship.

The current generation of AI tools, such as language learning models and image generators, continues to be a topic of debate among developers. Critics argue that these tools are not the magical labor-saving devices they are often portrayed as. Each AI creation requires the labor of thousands of low-income workers, and some believe that they primarily serve the purpose of cost-cutting for CEOs and reducing workforces.

Despite these concerns, several game companies are exploring the potential of AI in their development processes. Stardock is using chatbox-style functionality to generate text lore while leaving the artistic aspects to human artists. Activision employs AI tools to screen for toxic behavior in multiplayer games, and Ubisoft uses a “Ghostwriter” tool to generate dialogue. The applications of AI in game development are diverse, and their effectiveness depends on how they are utilized.

Tom Hall has a history of working with cutting-edge technologies and welcoming new challenges. He reflects on his experience with early phone games and pioneering virtual reality in the 90s. He believes that exploring new platforms and solving unsolvable problems is a never-ending quest for game designers.

The interview with Hall also touches on his insights into DOOM level design and his desire to revive old properties like Ion Storm's Anachronox. Hall expresses his enthusiasm for creating a sequel or an HD version of Anachronox, a game that he believes shares similarities with Mass Effect and possesses a rich universe worthy of exploration.

While AI has the potential to revolutionize game development, striking a balance between its use and human creativity is crucial. As Hall highlights, AI should not lead to the homogenization of games but should instead serve as a tool to enhance the craft of game development.

Sources: The Conversation