Skip to content
  • by
  • News
  • 2 min read

The Witcher Season 4: Navigating the Challenges of the Books

The recent news of Henry Cavill stepping down as Geralt in The Witcher has left fans wondering how the series will handle this change. While the casting of Liam Hemsworth as the new Geralt has garnered attention, it may not be the show's biggest problem.

One of the challenges that The Witcher has always faced is how to remain faithful to the books while also adapting them for television. With each season, the task becomes more difficult as the original stories grow more complex. Straying from a faithful adaptation may have been a good decision in retrospect.

The switch from Henry Cavill to Liam Hemsworth may not be as seamless as the showrunners have claimed. Fans had hoped that the change could be explained through the source material, but it seems unlikely at this point.

However, the recasting issue is not the primary concern. The biggest hurdle is the plot itself. The first three seasons of The Witcher covered the events of the first two books, but things become more complicated with book three. The show is dependent on the dynamic of the found family that Geralt, Yennefer, and Ciri form. In the upcoming season, they will be separated for a significant amount of time, which poses a challenge for the show's narrative.

Adding to the complexity, The Witcher books are structured differently from traditional stories. They consist of interconnected narratives rather than a linear progression from point A to point B. Book three focuses on Geralt's search for Ciri, while she undergoes her own separate adventure, which is not part of that particular book. Yennefer's arc is also disconnected from the plot.

The challenge lies in adapting these disjointed arcs and cramming three books into one season to move the plot forward. Additionally, there is the unexplained change in Geralt's appearance with the new casting. It remains to be seen how Netflix will address these challenges and navigate the intricacies of the books in season 4 of The Witcher.

– EarlyGame: [source] – Netflix: [source]