Skip to content

What is the Risk-Free Rate Rule? A Complete Guide

Hey there! As a fellow finance geek who loves gaming and streaming, I know how confusing some of these financial terms can be at first. So let me clearly explain what the risk-free rate rule is all about.

The Risk-Free Rate Rule in Simple Terms

The risk-free rate represents the minimum return an investor can expect for taking zero risk. It‘s the theoretical rate of interest you could earn by investing in a completely safe asset with no chance of default.

Government debt like short-term Treasury bills are considered nearly risk-free and are commonly used to estimate the risk-free rate in practice. But in theory, the true risk-free rate is the "pure" time value of money with absolutely no risk.

Now that we have the basics down, let’s dive deeper into the details!

How the Risk-Free Rate is Determined

As we discussed, the theoretical risk-free rate is impossible to observe because all investments have some risk. So in the real world, the yields on safe government securities act as a proxy.

Common Proxies for Estimating the Risk-Free Rate

  • 3-month U.S. Treasury bill yield – Often used for evaluating short-term cash flows
  • 10-year U.S. Treasury bond yield – Better for longer-term cash flow analysis
  • LIBOR – Being phased out but was widely used historically

The most appropriate proxy depends on the investment time horizon being analyzed. Here’s a quick data snapshot of current yields across different maturities:

Security Yield
3-month T-bill 4.10%
5-year T-Note 3.46%
10-year T-Bond 3.60%

As you can see, longer maturity Treasury yields are higher to compensate investors for the added uncertainty over time.

The 10-year T-bond yield is a common benchmark for the long-term risk-free rate used in asset pricing models I‘ll explain later. But analysts adjust the specific proxy as needed based on the investment time horizon being evaluated.

Real vs. Nominal Risk-Free Rates

One important distinction is the difference between real and nominal risk-free rates:

Real Risk-Free Rate

The real risk-free rate excludes the impact of expected inflation. It represents the "pure" time value of money.

Nominal Risk-Free Rate

The nominal risk-free rate includes expected inflation. Treasury yields represent nominal rates actually observed in the market.

To estimate the real risk-free rate, you simply subtract the expected inflation rate from the nominal Treasury yield being used as a proxy.

Let‘s walk through an example:

  • 10-year Treasury yield = 3.60%
  • Expected inflation over next 10 years = 2.5%
  • Real risk-free rate = 3.60% – 2.5% = 1.10%

The real risk-free rate is useful for evaluating investments in "real" assets like physical equipment or property. The nominal rate is preferred when analyzing cash flows that rise with inflation, like rental or sales revenue.

Historical U.S. Risk-Free Rates

While risk-free rates are anchored by inflation expectations, they still fluctuate meaningfully over time as economic conditions evolve. Just take a look at how the 3-month T-bill rate has moved over the decades:

Average 3-Month T-Bill Rate by Decade

  • 1970s – 7.3%
  • 1980s – 8.5%
  • 1990s – 4.6%
  • 2000s – 2.0%
  • 2010s – 0.4%
  • Current – 4.1%

Rates peaked during the high inflationary 1970s and 80s before falling to multi-decade lows in the 2010s. In today‘s rising rate environment, Treasury yields have climbed back up as the Fed tightens monetary policy to fight inflation.

So while risk-free rates tend to follow the general level of interest rates over time, be aware they still fluctuate meaningfully in the short-run!

Using Risk-Free Rates in Lease Accounting

One key application of risk-free rates is in lease accounting under ASC 842. Here‘s a quick overview of why risk-free rates matter:

Risk-Free Rates and Lease Discount Rates

Under ASC 842, lease liabilities are recorded at the present value of future payments. To calculate PV, analysts need to discount the payments using an appropriate rate.

If the rate is not explicitly stated in the lease, ASC 842 requires using the lessee‘s incremental borrowing rate (IBR). The IBR starts with a risk-free rate benchmark corresponding to the lease term and adds the lessee‘s credit spread.

So getting the risk-free rate right is crucial for estimating the IBR and valuing lease liabilities!

Best Practices for Selecting Risk-Free Rates

Based on ASC 842 guidance, here are some tips for choosing the right risk-free rate as a starting point for the IBR:

  • Match the Treasury security maturity to the lease term – e.g. 5-year yield for a 5-year lease
  • Use prevailing yields at lease commencement, not at period end
  • Average yields over a reasonable lookback period to smooth volatility
  • Document the methodology as an accounting policy

Getting the risk-free rate correct provides the foundation for reasonable discount rates and lease liability balances under ASC 842.

How Risk-Free Rates Are Used in Asset Pricing Models

Beyond lease accounting, risk-free rates also play a vital role in asset pricing models that analysts use to estimate required returns on investments.

The most common examples include:

Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM)

CAPM Equation:
Expected Return = Risk-Free Rate + Beta × (Market Risk Premium)

The risk-free rate sets the baseline required return before factoring in the investment‘s relative riskiness.

Arbitrage Pricing Theory (APT)

APT uses the risk-free rate as the starting point and then adds risk premiums tied to various macroeconomic factors.

Build-Up Method

With the build-up method, the risk-free rate serves as the "floor" required return before adding other risk premiums to estimate the cost of capital.

So in summary, the risk-free rate provides the foundation for determining the return investors demand on risky assets through these models.

Comparing the Risk Premium and Risk-Free Rate

The risk premium is the extra compensation investors require above the risk-free rate to take on additional risk. The higher the risk, the larger the risk premium.

Key Differences

Risk-Free Rate

  • Return on an investment with zero risk
  • Used as the minimum baseline required return
  • Approximated using Treasury yields

Risk Premium

  • Extra return demanded above the risk-free rate
  • Compensates investors for incremental risk taken
  • Varies based on asset type and risk level

Let‘s walk through a quick example:

  • 10-year Treasury yield = 3.60%
  • Equity risk premium = 5%
  • Required return on stocks = 3.60% + 5% = 8.60%

So in this case, the 5% equity risk premium is the extra return stocks must offer above the "risk-free" Treasury yield to compensate investors for the additional risk.

Limitations of the Risk-Free Rate Concept

While the risk-free rate is a core building block in finance, a few limitations exist:

  • No such thing as a truly risk-free asset in practice
  • Government default risk, although minimal, still exists
  • Treasury yields influenced by supply/demand, not just risk
  • Reinvestment rate uncertainty still present

For these reasons, observed Treasury rates provide practical estimates of the theoretical "true" risk-free rate.

The risk-free rate is still an indispensable tool for analysts. But it‘s best to keep these limitations in mind and not treat any observed rate as absolute zero risk.

The Bottom Line

And there you have it! Now you know the essentials of what the risk-free rate is and how analysts use it for tasks like lease accounting, estimating cost of capital, and asset pricing models.

While the theoretical risk-free rate doesn‘t actually exist, Treasury yields provide sensible proxies to serve as a benchmark "floor" for required returns on risky investments.

Hope this guide provided a helpful intro to the risk-free rate rule for you as a fellow finance and investing geek! Let me know if you need any clarification on these concepts.